Design4 min readOpus 5.5 wins · Astra next

Opus 5.5 vs ChatGPT 6.2 Sol: Opus wins the PDFCheck redesign

6.2 Sol made the better-looking homepage in about 35 minutes. It also changed what the product promises and cut most of the page, so Opus 5.5 wins 3 to 1. Astra is next on the same scorecard.

Screenshot Opus 5.5 beats ChatGPT 6.2 Sol 3 to 1. Both pages are real captures from 18 Nov: the live site left, Sol's prototype right.
3 to 1Opus 5.5 over 6.2 Sol
35 minfor two Sol redesigns
3×live page length vs Sol
—Astra, not run yet
PDFCheck.onlineFree PDF editor
#1
Waiting on GoogleResubmitted 1 Oct, no answer recorded yet
Visitors
695
Last 24 hours
Revenue
—
Not split by project yet
Google AdSense View product Weekly recaps for PDFCheck.online →

The short version

  • Opus 5.5 wins, 3 checks to 1. ChatGPT 6.2 Sol made the better-looking PDFCheck homepage and lost on everything else.
  • Sol's pages promise your file never leaves your device, which isn't how the checker works. They also drop the sign-up card, half the tools and most of the help text.
  • Three Sol ideas are worth testing on the live page. ChatGPT 6.2 Astra gets the same page, brief and scorecard next.
  • I also tried GPT-6.2 on Aimantas.com. I liked the article layout and picked Opus 5.5 with Fable 5.2 for the site overall.

Opus 5.5 wins, 3 to 1

ChatGPT 6.2 Sol made the better-looking PDFCheck homepage. The Opus 5.5 page wins because it still does the job.

On 18 November I gave the PDFCheck.online homepage to ChatGPT 6.2 Sol for a redesign. About 35 minutes later it had two new versions, each with its own test script. Both look great. Both also change how the product works and cut most of what the page is for, so the live page stays.

CheckOpus 5.5, liveChatGPT 6.2 SolWinner
LookClean, but plainHuge type, one strong green, your PDF's first page on screenSol
Matches how the checker worksUploads the file, runs ten checks, deletes itPromises the file never leaves your deviceOpus
Sign-up and free checksGoogle sign-up card, 100 free checks a dayBoth goneOpus
Tools and help text12 tools, a how-to and a long FAQ6 tools and three questionsOpus
PDFCheck.online live homepage: the headline Who made this PDF, and when was it changed, an upload box, a sample report card with author, software, dates and AI indicators, and a sign-up card below it.
ScreenshotThe live page. Opus 5.5 built the layout and report card; Fable 5.2 added the hex pattern on 13 November. pdfcheck.online, 18 Nov.

What 6.2 Sol built

It started by screenshotting the live page. Option 1 kept the light layout and put the sample report on top of a generated photo of a scanner. It's tidy. It's also a picture of scanning paper, and PDFCheck reads files.

6.2 Sol option 1: the headline Look inside your PDF on a pale background, an upload box with a dashed border, and on the right a generated photo of a scanner with a green laser line, with the sample report card laid over it.
ScreenshotOption 1. The report card is copied from the live page, same file, same Jane Smith. Local prototype, 18 Nov.

For option 2 it drew mockups first and then built them almost exactly. This is the good one. A dark green hero, a real sample PDF rendered beside its details, and the two save dates on a small timeline with the gap written out: 37 days later.

A generated mockup: a dark green page with the huge pale green headline Who made this PDF, a green Choose a PDF button, and a sample file called Handover brief shown as a page beside a Document details panel.
MockupThe image 6.2 Sol generated before writing any code for option 2.
6.2 Sol option 2 as built: the dark green hero and headline, the Choose a PDF button with Files stay on your device under it, and the Handover brief sample rendered as a real page beside Document details.
ScreenshotOption 2 as built. The page on the left is the sample PDF rendered in the browser. Local prototype, 18 Nov.
Live PDFCheck.online on a phone: centred headline, the upload box with Choose a PDF, three trust points and a bottom tab bar.
ScreenshotOpus 5.5: upload first.
6.2 Sol option 2 on a phone: big headline, full-width Choose a PDF button, then the sample report with Metadata and Page preview tabs.
Screenshot6.2 Sol: details first.

The app reported 15 minutes 19 seconds for option 2. Sol also wrote Playwright checks for sideways scrolling, the upload button's position and a real upload. One screenshot at 14:53 shows the sample text drawn without spaces between words; the build two minutes later is fine.

Why Opus still wins

Sol redesigned the product along with the look. Both versions say "files stay on your device". The live checker uploads the file, runs ten checks and an AI scan on the server, then deletes it. To ship Sol's page I'd have to rebuild the checker in the browser or change the promise. Its summary mentions neither.

It also cut most of the page: the sign-up card, the free checks counter, half the tools, the how-to and nearly all of the FAQ. Here are all three at the same scale.

Three full-length homepages side by side at the same scale. The live page runs 6,338 pixels with a tools grid, a long FAQ and a large footer. 6.2 Sol's two options stop at 1,954 and 2,055 pixels.
ScreenshotFull pages at 1440 pixels wide. The live page is three times longer.

A shorter homepage might be right one day. That's a decision about search traffic and sign-ups, and I'd rather make it with numbers than as a side effect of a new look.

Three of Sol's ideas are worth stealing, one at a time: your PDF's first page next to its details, the save dates on a timeline, and details first on phones. The page preview goes first.

Next: ChatGPT 6.2 Astra

Same page, same brief, same scorecard. Astra's column stays empty until it runs.

CheckOpus 5.56.2 Sol6.2 Astra
LookWin—
Matches how the checker worksWin—
Sign-up and free checksWin—
Tools and help textWin—
Score31Not run yet

The plan:

  1. Astra gets the brief Sol got and starts from the same live page.
  2. I capture its result at 1440 and 390 pixels, plus the full page length.
  3. It's scored on the same four checks. To beat Opus it has to keep how the checker works, or say plainly what it changed.
  4. Whatever wins a row gets tested on the live page, and I post the before and after numbers either way.

Battle 2 on Aimantas.com

Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.2 still win for me. I’m keeping their design for this site.

This time I gave GPT-6.2 my homepage, an article and the projects page. Its first pass put a drawing of an old computer where my projects usually sit. I liked the drawing. I wanted the projects back up top.

The Opus and Fable homepage on the left puts weekly figures below the project cards. The GPT-6.2 homepage on the right puts the latest writing there.
ScreenshotBoth versions put my projects up top. Immediately below them, the live site shows the week’s numbers. GPT-6.2 goes straight to the latest writing. 18 November.

The computer found a spot farther down the homepage, beside my avatar. Pick World Survey and a geography lesson plays inside the little monitor. Try it on the GPT-6.2 workbench.

I liked the new article layout. On desktop I can read the headline and see the screenshot beside it. The projects page also improved on the second pass. At 390 pixels wide, I could see the PDFCheck iPhone release, World Survey, Shotbar and three full table rows before scrolling.

Compare the article and projects pages
The live PDFCheck launch article beside the GPT-6.2 reader. On desktop the redesign pairs the headline with the two iPhone screenshots.
ScreenshotThe same PDFCheck launch story in both readers. GPT-6.2 gives the headline and the two iPhone screens a shared opening on desktop.
The live project leaderboard on the left, and the GPT-6.2 project index with a PDFCheck release, World Survey, Shotbar and the start of its table on the right.
ScreenshotThe live page opens with the leaderboard. The GPT-6.2 page makes room for the release and two more projects above it.

Where it stands 18 November 2026

Done

  • Two 6.2 Sol prototypes built and checked locally, 18 November
  • Scored against the live Opus 5.5 page: Opus wins 3 to 1

Not done

  • 6.2 Astra not run yet
  • Neither Sol prototype is in the PDFCheck app
  • No visitor test, tokens or cost recorded

Next

Run ChatGPT 6.2 Astra on the same page and brief, then fill in its column.

Sources8 references
  1. Run: the ChatGPT desktop app with file and command access, 18 November 2026, model ChatGPT 6.2 Sol. The app reported 'Worked for 15m 19s' for the pass that delivered option 2. File times, UTC+2: reference screenshots of the live page 14:21; generated scanner image 14:24; option 1 built and screenshotted 14:33 to 14:38; two generated mockups 14:43 and 14:44; option 2 built and screenshotted 14:45 to 14:55.
  2. Prototypes: standalone HTML, CSS and JavaScript, not wired into the PDFCheck app. Option 1 is 1,276 lines, option 2 is 851. Each folder is 2.0 MB, of which 1.93 MB is a bundled PDF.js build (pdfjs-dist 6.5.438); the type is Instrument Sans. Option 2 reads PDF version, page count, author, creating app, created and modified dates in the browser and renders page 1; option 1 also reads the producer. Option 2's sample is a 1,309-byte PDF it generated.
  3. Testing: Sol 6.2 wrote Playwright scripts that check for horizontal overflow, that the file button sits above the fold, and that uploading an edited copy of the sample shows the new author, app and a 37-day gap. An intermediate 14:53 screenshot shows the sample's body text drawn without word spaces; the 14:55 build renders it correctly.
  4. Live page attribution: of 146 PDFCheck.online commits since 20 September 2026 with a model trailer, 94 name Claude Opus 5.5, 28 Fable 5.1, 23 Fable 5.2 and 1 Sonnet 5.5. The homepage layout and sample report card are Opus 5.5 work; the animated hex pattern behind the hero was added by Fable 5.2 on 13 November.
  5. Live page copy read on pdfcheck.online on 18 November 2026: 'Ten quick checks flag common problems', 'PDF deleted after the check', '100 free checks today', a sample report with an AI indicators row, a sign-up card and 12 tools in the home page grid.
  6. Screenshots: 18 November 2026, headless Chrome, light mode, reduced motion, 1440 × 900 and 390 × 844 at 2x. The live site is pdfcheck.online with its cookie notice hidden; the prototypes were served locally. Full page heights at 1440 pixels: live 6,338, option 1 1,954, option 2 2,055. Images marked Mockup were generated by 6.2 Sol before it built option 2.
  7. ChatGPT 6.2 Astra: not run as of 18 November 2026. Its scorecard column is empty until it is.
  8. Battle 2. Screenshots of aimantas.com and the reviewed GPT-6.2 version, captured on 18 November 2026 at 1440 × 960 and 390 × 844. The winner is my design preference.

Weekly recap · one email a week

Get the weekly recap.

  • The week’s numbersTraffic and growth for every project.
  • The newest articleWhat I built, broke or changed, with screenshots.
  • One thing worth tryingA tool, setting or tactic from the week.

The list is open now; the first email goes out once sending is set up end to end. Unsubscribe anytime, and your email stays private. How I use it

Read past recaps →

esc

↑ ↓ move↵ open/ search anywhere

Get the weekly recap